The science
Compass
Yes/no reflective questions at each phase that nudge you back on course.
- Effect found
- g ≈ 0.28–0.34
- Studies pooled
- 21+
- Counted in our estimate
- Yes
What it does in Road Mates
At each phase the compass asks a few yes/no questions. They are short on purpose: you answer in seconds, and the answers feed the needle.
How it works
- Questions contrast where you are with where you want to be.
- They ask about obstacles so you can plan for them before they hit.
- Answers are private by default and never shown as a score to other members.
What the research found
Mental contrasting imagines the goal and then the obstacles in the way. Combined with if-then plans it is often called WOOP. A 2021 meta-analysis of 21 studies and about 15,900 participants found a small-to-medium effect on goal attainment (g = 0.336), larger when someone interacted with participants than with written materials alone.
A review focused on health behavior found g = 0.28 up to four weeks, rising to g = 0.38 up to three months.
Limits
- The authors warn publication bias may mean the true effect is smaller.
- Adding if-then plans on top of mental contrasting did not clearly add more in the health review.
Sources
- Wang et al. 2021 ↗
Meta-analysis of mental contrasting with implementation intentions.
- Cross & Sheffield 2019 ↗
Mental contrasting for health behavior change.